How To Replace A Hot Tub Heater

Are you frustrated by an uncooperative hot tub heater reducing your relaxation time due to irregular temperature shifts? With an efficient Hot Tub Heater Replacement, you can reinstate your peaceful and soothing evening soaks. This maintenance not only optimizes the performance of your hot tub but also ensures consistent water temperatures and enhances overall longevity. With this advancement, you can enjoy an uninterrupted oasis of tranquility while simultaneously saving potentially high repair costs in the long run. Discover how the replacement of a hot tub heater can serve as a cost-effective and wise investment to upgrade your wellness routine.

GOORIDA 220V 240V/3KW Spa Hot Tub Thermostat, Inflatable Pool Thermostat with Adjustable Temperature Fits for Bathtub, Above Ground Pools, Water Thermostat Replacement Parts

Key Takeaways: 

  • Replacement restores consistent water temperature and saves repair costs.
  • Frequent breaker-tripping temperature fluctuations signal a need for replacement.
  • Energy efficiency, compatibility, heater type impact replacement choice
  • Gas heaters heat quickly, which is great for large/regular use; electric heaters are often easier, safer, and more energy-efficient
  • DIY replacement is possible with adequate tools, precautions, and steps
  • Proper maintenance prolongs heater life and identifies signs of malfunction.

When Should You Replace Your Hot Tub Heater?

Replacing your hot tub heater is crucial for maintaining optimal performance and ensuring the safety of your spa. Here’s when you should consider replacing your hot tub heater:

1. Frequent Tripping of Heater

If your hot tub heater is constantly tripping the breaker, it may be due to an electrical issue or a damaged heating element. This problem reduces the heater’s efficiency and can become a safety hazard.

2. Unexpected Fluctuations in Hot Tub Temperature

When your hot tub heater struggles to maintain the desired temperature, it may be a sign of a damaged or worn-out heater. Inconsistent water temperature can lead to discomfort and an unsatisfactory spa experience.

3. Rising Energy Bills

An inefficient hot tub heater can lead to increased energy consumption, resulting in higher energy bills. It’s important to monitor your energy usage and consider replacing your heater if you notice a consistent spike in costs.

4. Rust or Damage to the Heating Element

Inspect your hot tub heater for any signs of rust or physical damage. Corrosion or damage can reduce the heater’s efficiency and even lead to water contamination or electrical issues.

5. Age of the Hot Tub Heater

Typically, hot tub heaters last between 5 to 10 years, depending on usage and maintenance. Regular servicing can prolong the life of your heater, but eventually, it will need to be replaced to maintain optimal performance.

Signs and Symptoms Indicating Potential Problems with the Hot Tub Heater:

  • The water temperature does not match the set temperature
  • Frequent tripping of the breaker
  • Unusual noises coming from the heater
  • Rust or corrosion on the heating element
  • Burning or scorched smell near the heater
  • Leakage around the heater

Pay attention to these signs and symptoms to determine when it’s time to replace your hot tub heater. Timely replacement can save you from potential hazards costly repairs, and ensure an enjoyable and relaxing hot tub experience.

How to Choose the Right Replacement Heater?

Choosing the right replacement heater for your hot tub involves various considerations, including energy efficiency, compatibility, and type of heater. Here’s how to go about it:

1. Energy Efficiency: Choose a heater that offers high energy efficiency to reduce operating costs. Look for heaters with energy-saving features and consider the heater’s British Thermal Unit (BTU) – higher BTU heaters are typically more efficient.

2. Size Compatibility: Check the size and capacity of your current heater to ensure you select a compatible replacement. Keep in mind the physical size of the heater, the voltage, and the amperage to ensure a proper fit and compatibility with your electrical system.

3. Heater Type: There are two primary types of heaters – electric and gas-operated. Both have their pros and cons, which need to be weighed against your requirements, preferences, and local energy costs.

4. Quality and Durability: Opt for a heater known for its durability and quality. A high-quality heater can serve you for a longer period, reducing the need for frequent replacements.

5. Brand Reputation and Warranty: Reputable brands often offer high-quality products and exemplary customer service. Choose a reliable brand that offers a good warranty.

Electric Vs. Gas Operated Heaters: Pros and Cons

Electric and gas-operated heaters are two common types of heating systems used in homes and commercial spaces. Each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Here’s a comparison of electric and gas heaters:

1. Electric Heaters

Memoryee Immersion Water Heater Portable Electric Stainless-Steel Heaters with Guard CoverSubmersible Home Instant Water Heater with and for Travel Camping Hot Bathtub Mini Inflatable Pool


  • They are usually easier to install.
  • They have higher energy efficiency ratings than gas heaters.
  • They have lower upfront costs.
  • They are considered safer as they don’t involve combustion gases.


  • They may require a significant amount of time to heat the spa water.
  • They can lead to higher energy bills if local electricity costs are high.
  • Electric heaters may require substantial electrical resources, potentially needing an upgrade to your home’s electrical system.

2. Gas Heaters

TCFUNDY 1.58 GPM Tankless Water Heater Propane Gas 6L, Instant Hot Water Heater, Portable Digital Display Gas Water Heater, with Shower Head


  • Gas heaters can heat the hot tub water quickly.
  • They are excellent for larger spas or those used regularly.
  • Depending on local gas prices, operating costs may be lower than electric alternatives.


  • They have higher upfront costs for the unit and installation.
  • Gas heaters can be less efficient than their electric counterparts.
  • They might require additional venting or an external propane tank, depending on the type of gas used.

Ultimately, your choice between an electric and gas-operated heater should be guided by factors such as your budget, how often you use your hot tub, the climate in your area, and the relative cost of electricity and gas.

Step-by-Step Guide on Hot Tub Heater Replacement

Replacing a hot tub heater yourself can save you money and ensure the job is done to your satisfaction. Before you start, make sure to gather the necessary tools and follow safety precautions. Note that this guide assumes you are replacing the heater with a similar model. If major modifications are required, it’s best to consult a professional.

Necessary Tools:

  • Screwdriver
  • Wrench
  • Wire stripper
  • Multimeter
  • Replacement hot tub heater
  • Plumber’s tape


  • Turn off the power to the hot tub at the breaker. Ensure no electrical current is flowing before starting work.
  • Drain the hot tub to avoid any water damage or accidents.
  • Make sure you have the appropriate replacement heater for your hot tub model.

Step-by-Step Guide:

Step 1: Disconnect the Old Heater

  1. Locate the heater within the hot tub cabinet. It is usually found near the control box.
  2. Remove the front panel of the heater. This will expose the heater connections.
  3. Disconnect the heater wires (line-in and line-out) using a screwdriver or wrench. Note the orientation of the wires for reconnection later.
  4. Disconnect the pressure switch and any sensors from the heater assembly if present.

Step 2: Remove the Old Heater

  1. Using a wrench, loosen and remove the unions that connect the heater to the spa plumbing.
  2. Carefully remove the old heater from the hot tub cabinet.

Step 3: Install the New Heater

  1. Position the new heater in the hot tub cabinet, aligning the plumbing connections.
  2. Attach the new heater to the plumbing by tightening the unions with a wrench. Use the plumber’s tape on the threads for a watertight seal.
  3. Reconnect the pressure switch and any sensors.

Step 4: Connect the Wiring

  1. Strip the ends of the heater wires if necessary and connect them to the new heater in the same orientation as before (line-in and line-out).
  2. Tighten the connections using a screwdriver or wrench.
  3. Reattach the front panel of the heater.

Step 5: Test the New Heater

  1. Refill the hot tub and check for any water leaks around the heater connections.
  2. Turn the power back on at the breaker and start the hot tub.
  3. Set the desired temperature and check that the new heater is working correctly.

Step 6: Secure the Heater

  1. Once you’ve confirmed that the new heater is functioning properly, ensure it is securely fastened within the hot tub cabinet.
  2. Close and secure the hot tub cabinet.

By following this step-by-step guide, you can replace your hot tub heater and ensure optimal performance and efficiency. Always remember to take necessary safety precautions and consult a professional if you encounter difficulties.

Maintenance Tips to Prolong the Life of Your Hot Tub Heater

  1. Regularly clean the filters: Dirty filters can put a strain on the heater, as it will need to work harder. Clean filters at least once a month and replace them when needed.
  2. Maintain proper water chemistry: Test and adjust your hot tub water regularly to ensure the correct pH, alkalinity, and sanitizer levels, reducing the risk of heater corrosion and damage.
  3. Monitor water levels: Low water levels can cause the heater to overheat. Always maintain the recommended water level to prevent heater malfunction.
  4. Clean scale buildup: Mineral deposits and scale buildup can reduce the heater’s efficiency. Use a de-scaling product or seek professional help to maintain heater performance.
  5. Inspect the wiring: Regularly inspect the heater’s wiring for signs of wear or damage. Address any issues promptly to avoid further damage or electrical hazards.
  6. Schedule routine maintenance: Have your hot tub serviced annually by a professional to ensure all components, including the heater, are functioning optimally.

Professional Services vs. DIY – Which One to Choose When?

  • Choose a professional service for:
    • Major repairs or replacements, especially if significant electrical or plumbing work is involved.
    • Servicing and maintenance tasks that require special tools or expertise.
    • Tasks that need to comply with local building codes, safety regulations, or warranty requirements.
  • Choose DIY for:
    • Minor repairs, such as replacing a heater with a similar model
    • Simple maintenance tasks, such as water testing, filter cleaning, and basic troubleshooting.
    • Tasks that can be performed safely with the tools and knowledge you have.

Avoiding Common Mistakes During Self-Installation

  1. Disconnect power before starting: Make sure the hot tub is unplugged, or the breaker is turned off to avoid electrocution or other electrical hazards.
  2. Check compatibility: Ensure the replacement heater is compatible with your hot tub’s size, voltage, and amperage requirements.
  3. Follow manufacturer instructions: Some heaters may have specific installation instructions. Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines to avoid mistakes or complications.
  4. Replace connections and wiring when needed: Inspect all connections and wiring. If they show signs of wear or damage, replace them during the heater installation.
  5. Ensure a watertight seal: Use the plumber’s tape on the threads and tighten all connections to avoid water leaks and ensure proper heater performance.
  6. Test the heater before securing it: Run the hot tub and check for leaks, proper heating, and correct operation before fully securing the heater inside the cabinet.


Hot tub heater replacement can be a crucial investment in your wellness routine, providing consistent temperature control, superior performance, and increased energy efficiency. Regular maintenance and observation of potential signs of heater malfunction, such as frequent circuit breaker trips, rust, and unusual energy spikes, can help determine the need for replacement. While selecting a replacement heater, factors like energy efficiency, compatibility, heater type, quality, and brand reputation should be weighed. Additionally, the comparison of gas and electric heaters should be considered in view of your specific requirements. A DIY heater replacement can be economically efficient if executed with precision, using the correct tools and safety precautions; however, for major replacements, seeking professional help is advised. Implementing regular maintenance, avoiding common installation mistakes, and understanding when to choose professional services versus DIY tasks can extend your heater’s lifespan and optimize hot tub performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Heater Be Replaced on a Hot Tub?

Yes, a heater can definitely be replaced on a hot tub. Over time, due to wear and tear or mechanical issues, the heater of a hot tub might fail to function efficiently. In such cases, replacement is a necessary and feasible option. The replacement process involves identifying the type of heater currently installed, purchasing a new, ideally similar, unit (to ensure compatibility with your tub’s existing setup), and either hiring a professional or using DIY methods to install the replacement. Safety measures, such as switching off the power and draining the tub, must be taken during the installation. Following a systematic guide can ensure a successful replacement, restoring your hot tub to its optimal performance and efficiency.

How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Hot Tub Heater?

The cost to replace a hot tub heater varies widely based on several factors, including the type of heater (electric or gas), the heater’s brand, its energy efficiency rating, and whether you opt for professional installation or a DIY approach. On average, the cost of a new hot tub heater ranges from $100 to $500 just for the heater itself. Professional installation can add an extra $150-$200 to your total cost. It’s important to remember that while professional installation may be more costly upfront, it often comes with the assurance of proper installation, potentially saving you future repair costs.

How Often Does a Hot Tub Heater Need to Be Replaced?

The frequency of hot tub heater replacement depends on various factors, including usage, maintenance, and the quality of the heater. Generally, hot tub heaters last between 5 to 10 years with regular servicing and proper maintenance. It is crucial to monitor your hot tub for signs of heater malfunction, such as frequent circuit breaker tripping, unexpected temperature fluctuations, or apparent rust or damage. If you spot these early, you could save on extensive repair costs. It’s always best to consult with a professional if you’re unsure.

Are Hot Tub Heaters Universal?

No, hot tub heaters are not universal. While most heaters share some standard specifications, they still differ in several crucial aspects, such as size, power requirements (voltage and amperage), and connection types. For instance, some heaters are designed for specific hot tub brands or models and may not be compatible with others. Similarly, heaters also vary based on their energy source – they can either be electric or gas-operated. When choosing a replacement heater, it’s important to verify it is compatible with your hot tub’s size, voltage, and amperage requirements. Always check the manufacturer’s details or consult with a professional for the correct and most efficient replacement.

Also Read:

Make Your Own DIY Hot Tub Heater

Ways to Find a leak in a Hot Tub

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top